CBaum's game Reviews on Newgrounds

[The Submarine Game]

Why go to the trouble?

Sure this is a decently drawn and fully functional game and you deserve credit for that, but it is not original at all, and better versions of this game exist than yours, so as its creator, where do you see the value in this game? I would understand if this was an exercise for yourself in using flash that you submitted because you made it and might as well submit something you already worked on. It is a great accomplishment to the extent that it demonstrates your mastery of action script and what not, but there is not much in terms of creativity here as far as I can tell.

snakep responds:

Hi,

it brings some new ideas like the Oxygen, Speed-Up and Reverse to the game.

Your rights its not full of creativity but i was hoping its a funny little game to play. If you look at most games they arnt original but i guess thats rather normal than spaming a new genre or a revolutionary concept.

cheers

[Chase The Crave 2]

excellent

This was professionally made and it is hilarious but its not fully functional; I was unable to crash into anything no matter how hard I tried. I wish I didn't live in stupid Canada so that I could go to White Castle in real life.

[First timer]

This lacks everything

Before you submit something like this, think. Is this really unique at all? No. Anyone can find some actionscript codes, copy and paste them, and make a simple timer like this. I like the tip though. I voted high because it made me laugh histerically.

[Attractors Orbit]

Something is fishy

I think I might have seen this same thing somewhere else on the net before, but for all I know you put it there or Im just insane, so I wont blow the whistle because Im not sure if its stolen or not. If you made it good job. It was pretty fun for a few minute simple game type thing.

[!Hungry Blocks!]

Thats how you make a simple game good

I love the music and I admire that you are able to take a stale unoriginal game and make it fun. That requires alot of talent. Good job.

[Mother Russia]

The background was very well drawn.

You did a great job on the background, and it was fun to make snow, however its not really a game. Also, I think its neccesary to point out that Stalin was an infamous, ruthless, communist dictator. It was neat and the song was funny, but add more of a game element in future submissions, because this was more of an interactive background then a game.

[-Alien Escape-]

the reason i gave you all zeros

is because you need to remove this game. Rather than resubmitting the same game with the fixed spelling, why dont you simply update the other game with the fixed swf file. if this passes judgement than either remove the other one, or remove this and edit the other one. ty

[Mouse Maze!!!!!]

i used uber right click hax

you can cheat by right clicking and moving over the grey to the cheese.

[Kill Bob 2]

Just a question.

If your english is bad then why is the english in the game correct?

Toady1104 responds:

Mmmm.... luck? I play many games in english...

[WindoofPX]

Well, i do like these window sims

but they have been done so many times and the jokes are always the same. I voted 5 cause i like this style but really it needs some knew jokes.